Republican Party

The Republican party is one of the two major political parties in the United States. The other is the Democratic party. The Republican party is popularly known as the GOP, short for Grand Old Party, an earlier nickname. Its first presidential candidate was John C. Frémont in 1856. Since then, through 2008, Republican presidents occupied the White House for 92 years. Traditionally, Republican strength came primarily from New England and the Midwest. After World War II, however, it greatly increased in the Sun-belt states and the West. Generally speaking, after World War I the Republican party became the more conservative of the two major parties. Its support has come from the upper-middle class and from the corporate, financial, and farming interests. It has taken political stances generally in favor of laissez-faire, free enterprise, and fiscal responsibility. It has stood against the welfare state.

Scholars agree that the origins of the party grew out of the sectional conflicts regarding the expansion of slavery into the new western territories. The stimulus for political realignment was provided by the passage of the Kansas-Nebraska Act of 1854. That law repealed earlier compromises that had excluded slavery from the territories. The passage of this act served as the unifying agent for abolitionists and split the Democrats and the Whig party. "Anti-Nebraska" protest meetings spread rapidly through the country. Two such meetings were held in Ripon, Wis., on Feb. 28 and Mar. 20, 1854; attending them were a group of abolitionist Free Soilers, Democrats, and Whigs. They decided to call themselves Republicans—because they professed to be political descendants of Thomas Jefferson's Democratic Republican party. The name was formally adopted by a state convention held in Jackson, Mich., on July 6, 1854.

The new party was a success from the beginning. In the 1854 congressional elections 44 Republicans were elected as a part of the anti-Nebraskan majority in the House of Representatives; also, several Republicans were elected to the Senate and to various state houses. In June 1856, at the first Republican national convention, Sen. John C. Frémont was nominated for the presidency but was defeated by Democrat James Buchanan. During the campaign the northern wing of the Know-Nothing party split off and endorsed the Republican ticket, making the Republicans the principal antislavery party.

Two days after the inauguration of Buchanan, the Supreme Court handed down the Dred Scott v. Sandford decision; this decision increased sectional dissension and was denounced by the Republicans. At this time the nation was also gripped by economic chaos. Business blamed tariff reductions, and Republican leaders called for greater tariff protection. The split in the Democratic party over the issue of slavery continued, and in 1858 the Republicans won control of the House of Representatives for the first time. One Republican who failed that year was Abraham Lincoln; he was defeated in his bid for a U.S. Senate seat by Stephen A. Douglas.

At the second Republican national convention, in 1860, a hard-fought contest resulted in the presidential nomination of Abraham Lincoln. The Republican platform specifically pledged not to extend slavery and called for the following: enactment of free-homestead legislation, prompt establishment of a daily overland mail service, a transcontinental railroad, and support of the protective tariff. Lincoln was opposed by three major candidates: Douglas (Northern Democrat), John Cabell Breckinridge (Southern Democrat), and John Bell (Constitutional Union party). Lincoln collected almost half a million votes more than Douglas, his nearest competitor, but he won the election with only 39.8 percent of the popular vote.

Shortly thereafter, the Civil War began. Reverses on the battlefield, disaffection over the draft and taxes, and the failures of army leadership brought Lincoln and the Republicans into the 1864 election with small hope for victory. Party leaders saw the need to broaden the base of the party; accordingly, they adopted the name National Union party. Andrew Johnson of Tennessee, a "War" Democrat, was nominated as Lincoln's running mate. Significant military victories intervened before election day and contributed to Lincoln's overwhelming reelection. After Lincoln's assassination the Radical Republicans, led by Sen. Charles Sumner and Rep. Thaddeus Stevens, fought President Johnson's moderate Reconstruction policies. Ultimately, relations between Johnson and Congress deteriorated, culminating in impeachment of the president; he was acquitted by a single vote.

The defeat of the South left the Democratic party—closely allied with the Confederacy—in shambles. The Republicans, on the other hand, were in the ascendancy. With the election of Ulysses S. Grant, the Republicans began a period of national dominance that lasted for more than 70 years and was only occasionally breached by a Democratic victory. Between 1860 and 1932 the Democrats controlled the White House for only 16 years. Grant's administration, with its support from the northern industrialists who had made fortunes in the Civil War, became riddled with scandal and corruption—the worst in the nation's history. Grant was not personally involved, however, and was renominated in 1872. A split among the Republicans ensued: the more liberal elements, opposed to the harshness of the Radical Republicans on the Reconstruction issue and the scandals of the administration, broke away and took the name Liberal Republican party. They, along with a faction of the Democratic party, nominated Horace Greeley for president. Despite this opposition, Grant was reelected by a substantial margin. A continuation of the scandals along with the panic of 1873 caused the Republicans to lose control of the Congress in 1874 in one of the greatest turnovers in history. The Republicans did, however, emerge from that election with a new party symbol, the elephant, after it first appeared in a newspaper cartoon by Thomas Nast.

In 1876 the Republicans nominated a virtual unknown, Rutherford B. Hayes of Ohio. The warring factions of the party were reunited as Hayes promised to remove the federal troops from the South and urged civil service reform. The Democratic candidate, Samuel J. Tilden of New York, received the greatest number of popular votes; widespread charges of electoral irregularities, however, led to the appointment of a congressional electoral commission to review the results and decide who should receive disputed votes in four states. The commission, controlled by Republicans, granted all the votes to Hayes, thereby giving him the election by an electoral-college margin of 185 to 184.

The Hayes administration was tarnished by the means in which it came to office but was generally efficient. Hayes ended Reconstruction, reformed the civil service, and espoused sound money policies. All these actions were unpopular with the old-guard Republicans led by Roscoe Conkling, and Hayes did not seek a second term. Instead, James A. Garfield was nominated as the Republican candidate in 1880. Chester A. Arthur of New York was nominated for vice-president. After winning a close election, Garfield was assassinated and Arthur became president. In spite of a past record as a "spoilsman," one who placed the party faithful in government jobs, Arthur astonished many with his success in getting passed the Pendleton Act, creating a civil service based on the merit system. He was never able to gain control of his party, however, and was the only president denied renomination by his party's convention. James G. Blaine of Maine received the nomination instead and faced Democrat Grover Cleveland of New York in the 1884 election. In a campaign that became infamous as one of the dirtiest in history, Cleveland, aided by the mugwumps led by Carl Schurz, defeated Blaine by a narrow margin.

Much of Cleveland's presidency was dominated by debate over the protective tariff. In 1888, after Blaine declined to run, the Republicans chose Benjamin Harrison of Indiana as their nominee. Campaigning strongly in favor of the protective tariff, Harrison defeated Cleveland by an electoral vote of 233 to 168, although he received 100,000 fewer popular votes. For the first time in years the Republicans also captured both houses of Congress. The Republicans passed the Sherman Anti-Trust Act, admitted several new states to the Union, and passed the highly protective McKinley Tariff Act.

In the congressional elections of 1890 the party suffered its worst defeat since 1874. President Harrison, although not popular within his party, was renominated in 1892 but lost the election to Cleveland. This defeat was the worst the Republicans had suffered since the party's birth. A severe depression and the panic of 1893—and a generally lackluster Cleveland administration—provided hope for the Republicans. The advent of a surprisingly strong Populist party in 1892 siphoned off votes from the Republicans in the border states and from the Democrats in the South. Even so, the Populist thrust was relatively short-lived. By tying themselves too closely to free silver as a major issue the Democrats weakened themselves.

In 1896, William McKinley of Ohio became the Republican candidate after a campaign orchestrated by Mark Hanna, a Cleveland politician-businessman who feared the rise of populism and a decline in business prosperity. In what many political historians believe was the most significant election since 1860, McKinley beat William Jennings Bryan by a substantial margin. McKinley received support from the industrial Northeast and the business community. Bryan received his votes from agricultural areas, the South, the West, and from the laboring man. These alliances presaged those that were ultimately to shape the political coalitions of the first half of the 20th century. The Republicans had committed themselves to conservative economics—a stance that they consistently retained thereafter.

McKinley's first term was dominated by the 10-week-long Spanish-American War (1898) and the subsequent acquisition of Guam, Puerto Rico, and the Philippines and the annexation of Hawaii. These events increasingly thrust the United States into world politics. The only question regarding the Republican ticket in 1900 was who would replace Vice-President Garret A. Hobart who had died the previous year. Governor Theodore Roosevelt of New York was chosen. McKinley again defeated Bryan but was assassinated in 1901. Roosevelt was sworn in as president, inaugurating a remarkable era in American political history.

Under Theodore Roosevelt the country saw reforms in economic, political, and social life. Republicans took the lead in conservation efforts and, to the dismay of some old stalwarts, began implementing Roosevelt's trust-busting ideas. Roosevelt's overwhelming reelection in 1904 inaugurated a new era of regulatory legislation (see Government Regulation) and conservation measures. As he had promised, he chose not to run in 1908 and urged the party to nominate William Howard Taft of Ohio.

Taft defeated Bryan, who was running for the third time; Taft's style, however, and his conservatism alienated the liberals within the Republican party. Those liberals, led by Robert M. La Follette of Wisconsin, organized (1911) the National Progressive Republican League as a means of wresting party control from the conservatives. At the Chicago convention in 1912, Roosevelt challenged Taft for the nomination. Failing to win, Roosevelt bolted the party and ran as the Progressive party candidate. Thus split, the Republicans decisively lost the presidency to Woodrow Wilson.

In 1916 the Republicans nominated Supreme Court Justice Charles Evans Hughes, but Wilson's domestic record, his personal popularity, and his pledge to keep the United States out of the war in Europe were obstacles too great for Hughes to overcome. Despite Wilson's promises, the United States was drawn into World War I, and party politics gave way to bipartisan prosecution of the war. Republicans won control of the House of Representatives and the Senate in the 1918 elections and, at the end of the war, prevented the United States from joining the League of Nations by rejecting ratification of the Treaty of Versailles (see Paris Peace Conference).

The Republican ticket of Warren G. Harding and Calvin Coolidge won the 1920 election by a landslide. Harding's administration was plagued by scandals (see Teapot Dome), which were inherited by Coolidge after Harding's death in 1923. In a politically astute move, Coolidge appointed two special prosecutors to deal with the scandals, one from each party. Nominated in his own right in 1924, Coolidge was reelected by a large margin. In 1928, Coolidge declined to run again, and the Republicans turned to Herbert Hoover of California. Hoover won by an unprecedented landslide against Alfred E. Smith. Republicans also won control of both houses of Congress. Many believed that another era of Republican hegemony was dawning, but a rapidly escalating worldwide economic depression brought Hoover and his party to their knees. Although the Hoover administration took steps to stop the decline of the economy, its remedies were generally thought to be ineffectual and too late. Hoover was renominated in 1932 in the depths of the Depression of the 1930s, but Franklin D. Roosevelt defeated him in one of the great landslide victories in U.S. history. The 70-year era of Republicanism was at an end. One of Roosevelt's major accomplishments was wooing the black vote away from the Republicans.

The Republicans were unable to find a candidate who could match Roosevelt's popular appeal. Alf Landon and Wendell L. Willkie failed in 1936 and 1940, respectively. Mostly isolationist before World War II, the Republicans backed the war effort, a stance that was to lead to support—enunciated by Sen. Arthur H. Vandenberg—for bipartisan foreign policy after the war. The 1944 elections came at a critical time in the midst of World War II, and New York governor Thomas E. Dewey became the fourth Republican candidate to be overwhelmed by Roosevelt. In 1948, Dewey again was the Republican nominee, this time against Roosevelt's successor, Harry S. Truman. He conducted a lackluster campaign, lulled into complacency by polls and expert opinions that forecast a landslide Republican victory. Truman, however, defeated Dewey in a great upset.

In 1952 the Republican national convention nominated Gen. Dwight D. Eisenhower to head its ticket. Although the party was split over the defeat of conservative senator Robert A. Taft of Ohio for that nomination, its ticket went on to win a landslide victory, carrying 39 states. Eisenhower's running mate was California senator Richard M. Nixon. The 1956 ticket of Eisenhower and Nixon won another decisive victory, owing in part to Eisenhower's moderate course in foreign policy, his successful ending of the Korean War, and his great personal popularity. Democratic control of both houses, however, won in 1954, was continued.

In 1960, Vice-President Nixon won an easy victory for nomination but lost the election to John F. Kennedy of Massachusetts by the smallest popular margin in the 20th century: a difference of only about 113,000 votes out of more than 68 million cast. After a bitter internal party struggle prior to the 1964 Republican convention, Sen. Barry M. Goldwater of Arizona wrested the presidential nomination and control of the Republican party away from the Eastern moderates; he thus began an attempt to convert the Republicans into an ideologically pure conservative party. His landslide defeat by Lyndon B. Johnson left the party organization in shambles, however.

In 1968, Richard Nixon reappeared to win the party's nomination; he selected Maryland governor Spiro T. Agnew as his running mate. Nixon went on to win the election over Democrat Hubert H. Humphrey, who was unable to bring his party together after divisions brought on by U.S. involvement in the Vietnam War.

President Nixon's first term was marked by many successes: improved relations with China, a more cooperative relationship with the USSR, an improved economy, and what appeared to be significant steps toward peace in Vietnam. In 1972 the Democrats nominated a prominent antiwar senator, George S. McGovern of South Dakota. Nixon was reelected by an enormous popular-vote margin, carrying every state except Massachusetts and the District of Columbia. Even so, the Democrats continued to control both houses of the Congress. The campaign, however, carried the seeds of the political destruction of President Nixon. A burglary of the Democratic National Committee headquarters in the Watergate office complex during the campaign led to revelations of widespread civil and criminal misconduct within the campaign organization, administration, and White House; impeachment hearings were held, and eventually Nixon resigned in 1974. An earlier scandal involved Vice-President Agnew, who was forced to resign in 1973 after being convicted of income-tax evasion.

Nixon was succeeded by Vice-President Gerald R. Ford, who had been appointed to the office after the resignation of Agnew. Ford faced a serious economic situation: high unemployment, rising inflation, high interest rates, and huge budget deficits. He was criticized by moderates for doing too little to allay the nation's economic ills and by conservatives for offering amnesty to Vietnam-era draft evaders and for appointing Nelson Rockefeller to the vice-presidency. After a difficult primary contest against conservative Ronald Reagan of California, Ford lost the election to Democrat Jimmy Carter.

By 1980 the apparent inability of the Carter administration to control the economic situation, coupled with a perception of U.S. impotence abroad (exemplified by the Iranian hostage crisis), favored a Republican resurgence. Reagan easily won the party's presidential nomination (his most liberal opponent, John Anderson, subsequently ran as an independent) and went on to overwhelm Carter, taking 489 electoral votes (against Carter's 49) and 51 percent of the popular vote. At the same time, the Republicans won 12 additional seats in the U.S. Senate, taking control of that body for the first time in 25 years.

This Republican resurgence, however, was only partially confirmed in the 1984 elections. Although in his reelection bid Reagan routed Walter F. Mondale, taking 59% of the popular vote and a record-breaking 525 electoral votes (to Mondale's 13), the Republicans lost two Senate seats but retained a majority. Democrats continued to control the House. The pattern of Republican presidential triumphs and Democratic gains in Congress continued in 1986, when the Democrats regained a majority in the Senate, and 1988, when George Bush won the presidency by a large margin.

President Bush's approval rating reached an impressive 89% in 1991 after the international coalition he forged against Iraq achieved victory in the Persian Gulf War. However, a recession that began in 1990, combined with the electorate's growing concern with domestic issues in the aftermath of the cold war and public impatience with "gridlock" in the government, counted against him in his reelection bid. Led by Bill Clinton, the Democrats in 1992 captured the presidency (with 370 electoral votes to Bush's 168) and solid majorities in both houses of Congress. In 1994, having blocked Clinton's legislative agenda, the Republicans mounted an aggressive midterm election campaign, engineered by Rep. Newt Gingrich, and seized control of both houses of Congress. In 1996, however, the Republican presidential candidate Robert Dole failed to unseat Clinton.

When the 1998 midterm elections were held, the Republicans expected to profit from months of bad publicity for the president in connection with the Whitewater affair. As it turned out, they not only failed to make the gains they hoped for but actually suffered some losses to the Democrats. Nevertheless, the GOP still maintained its control of Congress, and in December 1998 the Republican majority in the House carried through the impeachment of President Clinton. In the Senate trial, however, some Republican moderates joined the Democrats to acquit the president by a solid margin. Opinion polls showed considerable hostility toward the Republican party for having pursued impeachment. This attitude seemed to have faded by the summer of 2000, when a notably upbeat Republican National Convention formally nominated Gov. George W. Bush of Texas, son of the former president, as the party's presidential candidate. The vice-presidential nominee was Richard B. Cheney, secretary of defense in the Bush administration. The presidential election was a virtual tie between the Republican team and Democrats Al Gore and Joseph Lieberman. Although the Democrats won the popular vote, Bush and Cheney edged them in the electoral college by virtue of a disputed vote in the state of Florida. In the congressional elections of 2000 the Republicans held on to a slender majority in the House; in the Senate each party held 50 seats, leaving the tie-breaking vote in the hands of the new Republican vice-president. By May 2001, however, Democrats had gained a majority in the Senate following Vermont senator James Jeffords's departure from the Republican party to become an Independent.

In the midterm elections of 2002 the Republicans gained control of both houses of Congress, a rare accomplishment in such elections. Credit for the victory was given to President Bush, whose popularity with the electorate seemed to sway many close contests for both Senate and House seats toward the Republicans. In the 2004 elections President Bush and Vice-President Cheney defeated their Democratic opponents, Senators John Kerry and John Edwards, in a close race, while the Republicans added to their majorities in both the Senate and the House, giving them firm control of the government. The party's strategy of energizing its strong base of religious and socially conservative voters and getting them to the polls was credited as the deciding factor in its victory.

In the 2006 midterm elections, a series of corruption scandals and the public's negative view of the Iraq War led to a poor showing for Republicans; the GOP lost control of both the House of Representatives and the Senate. They also dropped from 28 to 22 governorships.

The 2008 elections were equally disappointing for the Republicans. The country faced ongoing wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, the meltdown of the U.S. financial system, ballooning unemployment, and other serious issues. As a result, President Bush was extremely unpopular with voters and Republican policies were increasingly seen as ineffective or marginal. Arizona senator John McCain, the Republicans' presidential nominee, selected Alaska governor Sarah Palin as his running mate. The pair were soundly defeated by the Democratic team of Barack Obama and Joe Biden. The Republicans lost multiple seats in both the Senate and the House. They dropped one governorship as well. These defeats left the party's leadership considering dramatic changes to the party. The loss of the one governorship was overcome in early 2009, however. On January 21, Jan Brewer, a Republican, succeeded Janet Napolitano, a Democrat, as governor of Arizona. Napolitano had resigned as Arizona governor of Arizona to become secretary of homeland security in the Obama administration. The November election defeats left the party’s leadership considering dramatic changes to the party. Michael S. Steele, former lieutenant governor of Maryland, took over as the party's national chair. He was the first African American to hold the post.

The GOP lost five U.S. House special elections in 2009. Yet the party rebounded somewhat in late 2009 and early 2010. In the November 2009 elections, Republicans won the governorships of New Jersey and Virginia. They also prevailed in a January 2010 special election to fill a Massachusetts U.S. Senate seat. It had been vacated by the death of Edward M. Kennedy. State senator Scott Brown defeated the state's attorney general Martha Coakley. Brown was the first Republican to be elected to the U.S. Senate from Massachusetts since 1972. His election gave the Republicans 41 seats, ending the Democrats' short-lived filibuster-proof majority. The GOP was successful in two of the four U.S. House special elections held during the first six months of 2010.

The Tea Party, a grassroots political movement focusing on fiscal conservatism, developed in the United States in 2009. The informal movement opposed what its members saw as excessive government spending. Tea Party rallies were held throughout the country. Originally independent of either major political party, the movement became a force within the GOP in 2010. Tea Party advocates endorsed a number of Republican candidates for congressional and gubernatorial contests in 2010, sometimes challenging and defeating Republican "establishment" candidates in primaries. A number of Tea Party activists, however, remained critical of both parties and suspicious of Republican intentions.

In the run-up to the 2010 midterm elections, Republicans stoked popular anxiety over economic malaise and continuing high unemployment. They denounced the Obama administration's policies as "socialist" and called for reduced taxes, reduced spending, and reduced deficits, although candidates rarely offered specific policy proposals. In the elections the Republicans won 60 more seats in the House, a historically large shift, and retook control. In the Senate, they reduced the Democratic majority to 53. They also took nine governorships. Within the Republican victories, the Tea Party's results were mixed. Several Tea Party candidates won victories, including the Senate races in Florida and Kentucky. In the Senate races in Nevada and Delaware, however, which the Republicans had expected to win, Democrats defeated Tea Party–endorsed candidates who were widely viewed as too extreme or too "flaky."

The divided Congress produced few positive results in 2011 and 2012. Democrats fended off Republican efforts to undo President Obama's health-care reform; Republicans were also largely frustrated in their attempts to impose austerity. For the presidential election, the GOP nominated Mitt Romney, an equity-capital investor and former Massachusetts governor. Beginning with a reputation as a moderate, Romney assumed strongly conservative positions in the primaries in order to win over the Republican base; he then moderated his positions in October to appeal to swing voters in the general electorate. In the election of Nov. 6, 2012, he lost to President Obama, 59.7 million to 57.1 million. Republicans retained control of the House but failed to win the Senate. Again, candidates associated with the Tea Party had mixed results. Ted Cruz, for example, won a Senate seat from Texas, but Tea Party candidates lost Senate races in Indiana and Missouri that Republicans had expected to win. In 2013 the Republican National Committee conducted an "autopsy" of the election, which focused on ways to expand the party's appeal. In particular, since Romney had won only 27% of the Hispanic vote, a growing sector of the electorate, the autopsy recommended efforts to win over at least part of that community.

In the 2014 midterm elections, Republicans increased their majority in the House by 13 seats (to 247-188). Only once before, in 1924, had the party won so many House seats. The GOP gained control of the Senate via a net gain of 9 seats (to 54-46). In the 36 gubernatorial elections held that year, Republicans had a net gain of 2 seats, giving them a total of 31. Republicans of all varieties performed well. Tea Party and establishment leaders of the party had sought to avoid conflict in these elections. Few Tea Party candidates challenged Republican incumbents. (In a significant exception, one defeated House majority leader Eric Cantor in a primary and went on to win the general election.) Many establishment candidates had adopted Tea Party rhetoric in their campaigns. Yet continuing divisions within the party threatened Republicans' ability to run Congress smoothly.

The 2016 presidential election brought out an unusual number of declared candidates, 17 in all. If nothing else, this made televised debates a logistical challenge. Most notable, however, was an apparent schism between the party "establishment" and its voter base. Perhaps spurred by exaggerated demands and promises made during past campaigns, many Republican voters had come to view their elected representatives as ineffective or corrupted. Thus, some of the most successful presidential candidates were those with the least connection to the party. Especially prominent was Donald J. Trump, a billionaire real-estate developer and television personality. With no experience in government or politics and little evident interest in policy details, Trump campaigned on his claims of superior intellect and competence. He appealed to middle-class anxieties in a time of economic uncertainty by denouncing illegal immigrants and unfair foreign-trade agreements and vaguely promising to "make America great again." He also drew support from white Americans anxious about the growing minority population. His remarks about immigrants—Mexican immigrants, in particular—undermined the party's hopes of improving its standing with Hispanic voters. His policy proposals, vague as they were, were often at variance with the party's positions. Thus he called for increasing spending on Social Security and Medicare and forcibly expelling all 11 million undocumented immigrants. He denounced lobbies, corporate interests, and the influence of rich campaign donors. He vowed to fund his campaign with his personal resources; in practice, he relied heavily on free television news coverage, which he attracted by making outlandish public statements. Another prominent candidate was Ted Cruz, the freshman senator from Texas. Although Cruz had more conventional credentials than Trump, he had spent his time in the Senate being uncooperative and chastising his own party's leaders. He blamed the GOP leadership for political failures, including predictable failures that he, himself, had caused. Thus Cruz was as despised by the leadership as Trump. Candidates favored by the establishment, however, were numerous and divided the anti-Trump/anti-Cruz vote among themselves. By early May, Trump had driven the other contenders out of the race and become the presumptive nominee. Despite his success in the primaries, Trump's approval ratings overall were abysmally poor. The party had selected a nominee who fulfilled neither of the usual criteria: electability and loyalty to the party and its principles. In July the party's two former presidents, the two most recent presidential nominees, the host-state governor, and nearly half the Senate Republicans refused to attend the convention. Cruz, who agreed to attend, gave a major address in which he failed to endorse the nominee; he admonished Republicans to "vote your conscience" in November. The pro-Trump delegates who dominated the convention then booed him off the stage on national television, symbolizing the divisions within the party.

Most Republican voters eventually rallied around the candidate, with the exception of some educated, white, suburban women. A number of prominent party leaders, however, either openly or tacitly refused to endorse him. Trump also had trouble extending his appeal to independent voters, although he performed well among white working-class men. He ignored virtually all the recommendations of the 2013 party autopsy. Although the polls predicted a narrow loss, and he lost the popular vote by 2.8 million, Trump won the electoral college with 306 votes versus Hillary Clinton’s 232 votes. The Republicans also retained control of the House and Senate, albeit with reduced majorities. Thus, as 2016 ended, the party's position in the country overall appeared strong. In addition to the White House and Congress, the GOP controlled the governorship and the whole legislature in 25 states, compared with five states for the Democrats.